How to Grade Pokémon Cards: PSA vs BGS vs CGC vs ACE Explained for Collectors

How to Grade Pokémon Cards: PSA vs BGS vs CGC vs ACE Explained for Collectors

You've pulled something special. Maybe it's a full-art ex, a vintage holo, or a card you've been hunting for months. The next question serious collectors always ask: should I get this graded?

Grading protects your card, authenticates it, and — for the right cards — can significantly increase its value. But not every card is worth grading, and not every grading company is the same. Here's everything you need to know.

What Is Pokémon Card Grading?

Card grading is the process of sending your card to a professional third-party company, who examines it under magnification and assigns it a numerical grade based on its condition. The card is then sealed in a tamper-evident hard plastic case (called a "slab") with a label showing the grade.

Graded cards are:

  • Authenticated — confirmed as genuine, not counterfeit
  • Preserved — sealed and protected from further wear
  • Standardised — given a universally recognised condition score
  • Tradeable — easier to buy and sell with confidence

The Four Grading Companies Collectors Use

PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator)

PSA is the most recognised name in card grading worldwide. A PSA 10 (Gem Mint) is the gold standard for Pokémon collectors and commands the highest premiums on the secondary market.

PSA grades: 1–10 (whole numbers only)
Turnaround: Varies from weeks to months depending on service tier
Best for: High-value vintage cards, chase pulls, cards you plan to sell or hold long-term
Reputation: Highest resale value, most liquid market

BGS (Beckett Grading Services)

Beckett grades on a 1–10 scale but also issues sub-grades across four categories: Centering, Corners, Edges, and Surface. A BGS 9.5 (Gem Mint) with four 10 sub-grades earns the coveted BGS Black Label Pristine — widely considered the most prestigious grade in the hobby.

BGS grades: 1–10 (including half-points, e.g. 9.5)
Sub-grades: Yes — Centering, Corners, Edges, Surface
Best for: Collectors who want detailed condition analysis, or cards chasing a Black Label
Reputation: Stricter than PSA; a BGS 9.5 is often considered equivalent to a PSA 10

CGC (Certified Guaranty Company)

CGC entered the Pokémon market more recently but has built a strong reputation quickly, particularly for modern cards. Their grading is considered strict and consistent, and their slabs are well-regarded in the community.

CGC grades: 1–10 (including half-points)
Best for: Modern sets, budget-conscious collectors, faster turnaround options
Reputation: Growing fast; good value for money on mid-tier cards

ACE Grading (UK-based)

For UK collectors, ACE Grading offers a domestic option that avoids international shipping costs and customs complications. Turnaround times are typically faster for UK submissions.

Best for: UK collectors grading mid-value cards where international shipping costs aren't justified
Reputation: Respected in the UK community; lower resale premium than PSA internationally

You can use code JUMP for 5% off Ace Grading :)

PSA vs BGS vs CGC: Quick Comparison

PSA BGS CGC
Scale 1–10 1–10 (half points) 1–10 (half points)
Sub-grades No Yes No
Strictness Moderate Strict Strict
Resale value Highest High Growing
Best for Vintage & high value Pristine modern cards Modern sets, value

What Grade Should You Aim For?

Grades matter enormously for value. Here's a rough guide to what each PSA grade means in practice:

  • PSA 10 (Gem Mint): Perfect or near-perfect. Four sharp corners, no print lines, perfect centring. This is what you're chasing.
  • PSA 9 (Mint): Excellent condition with only minor imperfections visible under close inspection. Still very desirable.
  • PSA 8 (Near Mint–Mint): Light wear. Noticeably lower value than a 9 or 10 for most cards.
  • PSA 7 and below: Visible wear. Generally only worth grading for very rare vintage cards where even lower grades carry value.

For modern Japanese sets, the bar is high — cards often come out of packs in near-perfect condition, so anything below a PSA 9 is a tough sell.

Is Grading Worth It? How to Decide

Grading costs money (submission fees, shipping, insurance) and takes time. Here's how to think about whether it's worth it for a specific card:

Grade it if:

  • The card's raw (ungraded) value is £30+ and a PSA 10 would meaningfully increase that
  • It's a vintage holo, first edition, or low-population card
  • You plan to hold it long-term or sell it on the secondary market
  • It came out of the pack in visually perfect condition

Don't bother if:

  • The card is worth less than £20–25 raw (fees will eat the upside)
  • It has visible wear — it won't grade well
  • You just want to play with it or display it casually

How to Submit Cards for Grading

  1. Check the card carefully — use good lighting and a loupe if you have one. Look at corners, edges, surface, and centring.
  2. Create an account on your chosen grading company's website (PSA, BGS, CGC, or ACE).
  3. Choose your service tier — faster turnaround costs more. Economy tiers are cheapest but slowest.
  4. Package your cards properly — use penny sleeves, then semi-rigid card savers or top loaders. Never use tape directly on cards.
  5. Ship with tracking and insurance — always.
  6. Wait — turnaround times vary. Track your submission on the grading company's portal.

Graded Cards at Jumping Jack Cards

If you'd rather skip the wait and buy already-graded cards, browse our Graded Pokémon Cards collection. We stock PSA and CGC-graded cards across vintage and modern sets, all authenticated and ready to add to your collection.

Looking to build a collection worth grading? Read our guide on how to build a Pokémon collection you actually care about.

Happy collecting. 🎴

Cover image from eBay

Back to blog